First Lie Wins

#1 New York Times Bestseller
USA Today Bestseller
Publishers Weekly Bestseller
Amazon Bestseller
Libro.fm Bestseller
Reese’s Book Club Selection for January
Book of the Month Club Main Selection
Amazon Top Pick for January
Reader’s Digest January Book Club Pick
Jordy’s Inaugural Book Club Selection
An Indie Next Selection
A Library Reads Selection

“Ingeniously plotted. . . Elston whips up plenty of suspense and delivers a satisfyingly serpentine finale. This promises more good things from Elston to come.” ―Publishers Weekly

“YA writer Elston’s adult debut announces itself as a savvy thriller with intrigue and momentum from the first twist… right up until the final showdowns. Evie is a smart and engaging protagonist, and her time on the run is anything but predictable. A genuine page-turner.”―Kirkus

“Buckle up. First Lie Wins features some of the best cat and mouse suspense I’ve read in years, while serving up plenty of heart along this wild ride. I’m still breathless.”―Lisa Gardner, #1 New York Times bestselling author of One Step Too Far

“First Lie Wins is a high-stakes thriller that brilliantly explores identity and love, truth and deception. Smart and sharp, fast-paced and twisty, this book kept me on the edge of my seat from the first page to the very last. Ashley Elston has crafted a truly unpredictable, unforgettable story. I loved it!”―Megan Miranda, New York Times bestselling author of The Last to Vanish

“Wildly inventive, diabolically clever….Filled with meticulously plotted details and stakes that will wholly consume you, Ashley Elston also delivers one of the most likeable, morally gray characters I’ve ever encountered. I devoured First Lie Wins and am now an Ashley Elston fan for life.”―Julie Clark, New York Times bestselling author of The Lies I Tell

“First Lie Wins is the most suspenseful game of deception I’ve ever read…. Ashley Elston peeled back layer upon layer of a carefully crafted plot, revealing a series of twists and reveals I never saw coming. Brilliant.”―Elle Cosimano, New York Times bestselling author of Finlay Donovan Is Killing It

“You don’t know who to trust in this taut and expertly plotted thriller from Ashley Elston. First Lie Wins is an edge-of-your-seat read that’s as emotionally moving as it is gripping. I loved every minute of it!”―Mary Kubica, New York Times bestselling author of Local Woman Missing

“A suspenseful and taut page-turner that is impossible to put down! First Lie Wins captivated me with its twisty premise and left me spellbound by the memory of its richly-drawn characters”―Megan Shepherd, New York Times bestselling author of Malice House

“Who is the cat and who is the mouse? It’s hard to tell when even the bad guys are so likable that you can’t help but root for them. Clever, twisty, and suspenseful, First Lie Wins kept me on my toes right up to the satisfying conclusion.”―Diane Chamberlain, New York Times bestselling author of The Last House on the Street

“Sharp, engaging, and unputdownable. Elston executes hair-pin turns masterfully, leaving readers gasping in surprise but firmly in their seats and ready for more. A smart suspense with romantic elements that keeps the thrills coming and the reader thinking of the story long after the book is done.”―Alyssa Cole, New York Times bestselling author of When No One is Watching

“Outstanding! The deeply woven characters in First Lie Wins pulled me in from the first page, then took me on a spellbinding ride. Ashley Elston has crafted an ingenious, unforgettable cat and mouse thriller!”―Wendy Walker, bestselling author of What Remains

“A whip-smart, twisty thriller with a surprisingly big heart. First Lie Wins is the type of book that begs to be read in one sitting.”―Kara Thomas, author of Out of the Ashes

“What a box of tricks! First Lie Wins flickers past like a shadow-play: just when you think you’ve worked out what you’re seeing, the shapes shift, the scene transforms, and — hold on — maybe you had it wrong a moment ago? Cool and clever and full-on fun, the sort of slippery high-stakes now-you-see-me-now-you-don’t thriller that few novelists are bold enough to attempt these days. Pick it up, please. This is a good one.”―A.J. Finn, #1 New York Times bestselling author of End of Story

“Prepare to trust no one on this high-speed thrill ride through timelines, identities, and motives as you work to piece together Elston’s expertly crafted puzzle. First Lie Wins is a fun, clever spin on the con artist novel, perfect for fans of The Lies I Tell and The Lady Upstairs.”―Ashley Winstead, author of Midnight is the Darkest Hour

“I really enjoyed this – very unexpected and pacy with a brilliant central character.”—Harriet Tyce, bestselling author of Blood Orange and The Lies You Told

“Absolutely brilliant. I devoured it.”—Heidi Perks, bestselling author of The Whispers

“An absolute CRACKER of a book—clever, original and compelling.”
—Rachel Abbott, bestselling author of Don’t Look Away

READERS GUIDE

Questions and Topics for Discussion

1. Identity plays a significant role in First Lie Wins. Evie assumes various aliases for her jobs and ultimately allows her Lucca Marino identity to take the fall for crimes she didn’t commit in order to protect her future. Why is the name Lucca Marino so important to her? Do you think your name is essential to your identity? Why or why not? And will she be happy as Evie Porter?

2. Evie and Ryan are both morally gray characters. Despite her life of crime, there were lines Evie wouldn’t cross: not leaving Miles unattended after his mother was injured, giving financial advice to Tyron, changing critical information about Ryan’s business so Mr. Smith wouldn’t be able to take it from him. Do you think this behavior redeems Evie in some way? Why or why not?

3. Evie’s path to crime began as a way to pay for the medicine and medical treatment her mother needed. In today’s world of high health-care costs, Evie believed she had no other option. Do you sympathize with Evie or think she was wrong to turn to a life of crime? Should she have continued in that line of work after her mother died? Discuss.

4. What are your thoughts on the author’s use of flashbacks? Did each flashback give you further insights into Evie’s actions or thought processes in the present? How so?

5. Evie’s mother dies when Evie is still quite young, yet rather than seek out community, she takes on a job that is inherently isolating. Why do you think it was so important for Evie to find the others who worked for Mr. Smith? Do you think Evie finally found her family with Devon, Amy, and Ryan? By the end of the book, do you think Evie has achieved what she originally hoped she might? What is the significance of her garden?

6. Evie leaves an origami swan behind when each job is complete. What do you think this specific calling card means? Do you think Evie enjoys the chase? Or is there a part of her that wants to be found out? Is it possible for both to be true?

7. Evie says, “There are the short cons and there are long cons and I’ve just finished the longest one of my life.” Did you know Evie was one step ahead of Mr. Smith the whole time? When did you realize who George was? Did you expect any of the reveals throughout the book?

8. Mr. Smith suggests that he and Evie are more alike than she might wish: they both con and manipulate others. Do you think Evie is aware of how much they actually resemble each other? At the end, it looks like Evie will take over Mr. Smith’s business—do you think that’s really what she wants? Can she do that job and also live happily ever after with Ryan?